Please register for Total War Access to use the forums. If you're an existing user, your forum details will be merged with Total War Access if you register with the same email or username. For more information please read our FAQ’s here.


Big problem with Gatling guns.

cephalocephalo MemberRegistered Users Posts: 60
I just lost a full stack of highly trained, highly upgraded elite infantry with full artillery support without them firing a shot. They were in a besieged castle town surrounded by five stacks of enemy troops. When you have many troops surrounding a castle, for some dumb reason the army that is besieged can not sally! This is a bug that I'm sure will never be fixed. There's a rule that an army can't enter an enemy's control circle without attacking that army, but when you are besieged, you can only attack the besieging army, and if that army is not the one with the overlapping control zone, your choice is inglorious surrender.

No use complaining about something that will never change, but how did 5 stacks of enemy troops come to besiege my castle? The answer is that the AI refuses to engage even a small army with Gatling guns. This really slows the game down a great deal. My army had attacked every one that came near, and as it was lugging around heavy Gatling guns, could not catch any enemy stack before they all eventually converged on the castle.

I suppose that the solution to this problem is to preserve the army over the castle, and let the enemy take it while I chase down the other stacks, but still, there are considerations like winter attrition to take in to account.

If you have more than one stack in a province, so that one can defend the castle and the other chase enemy stacks, the AI will bypass the whole province and attack behind your lines! It's a good strategy, but it really eats up the turns as the map is so huge it takes multiple turns to cross a province. At that point the AI is no longer trying to win, and completely devoted to making the player run out of time.

I'm wondering whether Gatling guns are just not worth the hassle. They can work if paired with a high level ninja, but otherwise they create problems.
Post edited by cephalo on


  • iceniiicenii Senior Member The PhilippinesRegistered Users Posts: 1,373
    edited January 2014
    Yeah just encountered that same problem, went back to S2TW after a break of about a year, was proceeding well in my campaign got besieged, unable to sally, lost full stack, luckily not elite troops like you. And it's not likely this will get fixed by CA so I would suggest looking on the Steam workshop to see if a mod fixes this problem or what I now do in a campaign is send my stacks out in pairs so 1 can attack while the other supports it and if besieged at least you have relief forces.
    I cannot force you to believe the truth but i can allow you to believe a lie. Quote by me " Icenii ".
Sign In or Register to comment.