Please register for Total War Access to use the forums. If you're an existing user, your forum details will be merged with Total War Access if you register with the same email or username. For more information please read our FAQ’s here.
(Quote) Green, sorry but your argument false apart with some simple logic. If it were true that "Attacks from spears toward monsters are akin to a grass leaf cut on your skin", then spear u… (View Post)
(Quote) Lotus you are trying to really nitpick. Of course 10 soldiers are not going to do 400 damage. It's just a random number I chose out of thin air. The damage could be something like this: (each… (View Post)
(Quote) The answer is no good could come of it. But my argument would be that whatever small buff to boxes this change would give, would be outweighed by the benefits of having this mechanic in all o… (View Post)
(Quote) The impact would be minimal. Say a frontal Cav charge causes 400 HP loss due to damage reflection. Is this extra loss of HP going to really tip the balance? If a box is already viable vs cav … (View Post)
(Quote) I agree it is unreasonable to expect a man-sized soldier to stop the momentum of a giant beast that can weight several hundred tons if not thousands. I never said anything to counter to this.… (View Post)